Numerical EM Modeling Questions2. Which electromagnetic modeling software should we purchase to help solve our EMC problems?This is truly a frequently asked question, since we receive regular emails and phone calls with this request. Unfortunately, it is a difficult question to answer without knowing the specific requirements of the person who is asking. The following points should be stressed and they apply to all numerical electromagnetic modeling codes:
Even with ideal codes and infinite computing resources, numerical modeling codes could not be used to predict the results of most EMC tests. This is partly because the tests themselves are well enough defined to ensure a repeatable outcome in every situation. However, it is primarily due to the fact that there are millions of parameters in a typical electronic system that may have a significant effect on the outcome of any given test. Product software, component transition times, material properties of insulators, and the RF impedance of metal-to-metal contacts are just a few examples. It is not possible to determine all of these properties and provide them to a numerical modeling code. So if you're looking for software that will help you estimate radiated emissions from electronic products or troubleshoot existing designs, don't expect numerical electromagnetic modeling codes to be of much help. However if you're looking for tools that can help you to really understand what is happening when the relevant geometries and materials are clearly identified, then numerical modeling tools are invaluable. The real strength of numerical tools is apparent when both models and measurements are employed. Measurements can be used to confirm that the models have included all the relevant parameters. Models on the other hand can be used to verify that measurements results were not affected by operator or equipment errors and that the quantity being measured is in fact the quantity of interest. Models confirmed by measurements are also able to provide a wealth of information that is not directly measurable, such as the fields or currents in inaccessible places. |