Evaluation of Electromagnetic Modeling Tools, October 2009

Other Ways to Model the Dipole Antenna

Modeling a Center-driven Dipole with IE3D

In this example, we can model the thin wire as a metallic strip, a rectangular tube or a tube with more sides. Using the "build wire path" command in MGRID, a round wire can be approximated by different geometry structures. By setting the number of segments for the circle to 6, the wire antenna is built with a cylindrical tube that has a hexagonal cross-section. If the number of segments for the circle is 4, the wire is built with a rectangle tube. If we set the number to 2, the wire antenna is built with a flat strip.

Comparing the 3 cases, the results for the hexagonal cross-section, the rectangular tube and the flat strip are shown in Figure 1.

input impedance plot
Fig. 1. Input impedances of tube with 6 sides, rectanglular tube, and flat ribbon models

The input impedances of the three models are very close over the frequency range evaluated. These results are shown in the following table.

Tube with 6 sides Tube with 4 sides
(rectangular tube)
Tube with 2 sides
(flat ribbon)

Zin at 150 MHz (Ohm) 83.9+j44.4 82.7+j45.1 83.2+j46.4
Resonant frequency (MHz) 144 144 144
Simulation time 59 seconds 23 seconds 1 second
Number of cells 912 604 152

The differences among the three models are quite small.

Reference:

[1] IE3D User's Manual, release 14.1, Zeland Software, Inc., May 2008.